Capitals vs Lightning prediction

Washington Capitals at Tampa Bay Lightning, Tuesday, November 17, 2026 · Benchmark International Arena. We simulated this game 10,000 times before puck drop, every shift and shot drawn from real play-by-play data for this matchup. Most plausible outcome: Lightning 3, Capitals 2.

Most plausible outcome

Washington Capitals2
Tampa Bay Lightning3

The likeliest final of 10,000 simulated games: the Lightning won 54% of them, and this is the result closest to both teams' middle scores.

Top performers

How it played out: every goal

  1. 1stTBL Guentzel, from Gourde and Kucherov 0–1
  2. 1stWSH Protas, from Leonard 1–1
  3. 2ndTBL Hagel, from Viel and McDonagh 1–2
  4. 2ndTBL Girgensons, from Guentzel and Carlson 1–3
  5. 3rdWSH Strome, from Chychrun 2–3

Box score

Capitals
PlayerGAPTSSOGPMPIMHITBLKTOIFO
Ryan Leonard0113102116:091-1
Dylan Strome1012100217:285-13
Aliaksei Protas1011100218:43
Pierre-Luc Dubois0004000017:458-13
Alex Ovechkin0004-102116:17
Jordan Kyrou0003000013:410-1
Tom Wilson0002-101117:372-4
Alex Tuch0001101218:273-7
Justin Sourdif0001-300011:025-10
Boone Jenner0000001214:509-13
Anthony Beauvillier0000-102010:090-2
Ilya Protas0000000012:48
Jakob Chychrun0110100026:38
Cole Hutson0003-102123:23
Matt Roy0001100015:58
Martin Fehérváry0001-101323:02
Timothy Liljegren0000-100113:05
Jack St. Ivany0000-123011:54
Capitals goalies
PlayerSASVGASV%TOI
Logan Thompson31283.90359:02
Lightning
PlayerGAPTSSOGPMPIMHITBLKTOIFO
Jake Guentzel1122100016:078-19
Brandon Hagel1014002016:18
Nikita Kucherov0113101118:083-3
Yanni Gourde0113002114:515-10
Zemgus Girgensons1012003021:276-11
Jeffrey Viel011112309:271-1
Pontus Holmberg0003203114:080-1
Gage Goncalves0002000115:220-2
Scott Sabourin0002-10107:55
Ilya Mikheyev0001020012:180-2
Sam O'Reilly0001-100111:57
Anthony Cirelli0001000016:228-15
John Carlson0111001118:26
Ryan McDonagh0111200220:08
Charle-Edouard D'Astous0002001119:20
J.J. Moser0001222224:03
Victor Hedman0001000113:27
Max Crozier0000-200124:16
Lightning goalies
PlayerSASVGASV%TOI
Andrei Vasilevskiy26242.92360:00

The breakdown

  1. The setup

    Capitals in net: Logan Thompson (expected), .897 save % over his recent starts.

    Lightning in net: Andrei Vasilevskiy (expected), .898 save % over his recent starts.

  2. Who's in the sim

    Capitals: Chychrun 24 · Roy 22 · Fehérváry 20 · Hutson 20 · Tuch 19 · Wilson 19 (minutes a night)

    Lightning: Guentzel 22 · Kucherov 21 · Carlson 19 · D'Astous 19 · Moser 18 · Hagel 18 (minutes a night)

  3. Things you'll notice in the sim

    Tuch scores in 29% of sims, the likeliest on the Capitals.

    Chychrun gets a point in 53%.

    Guentzel scores in 32% of sims, the likeliest on the Lightning.

    Kucherov gets a point in 64%.

    Overtime in 22% of sims (shootout 11%).

  4. What swings it

    When Thompson stops 92% or more (34% of sims), they win 79%, up from 46%.

    When Vasilevskiy stops 92% or more (35% of sims), they win 85%, up from 54%.

    When Lightning score a power-play goal (46% of sims), they win 68%, up from 54%.

  5. Reality check

    Capitals score 3.4 a game (last 15). In the sims: 3.1 against this goalie and defense.

    Lightning score 3.87 a game (last 15). In the sims: 3.4 against this goalie and defense.

  6. The 10,000 vs the market

    The Lightning win 54% of the 10,000 games.

    Total 6.5: over in 50%.

    The sims are not built to beat the spread: on past games the side they favored covered about half the time.

This week's simulations

How it works

Every shift puts real lines on the ice by their own ice time at even strength, on the power play and the penalty kill; each skater shoots from his own spots against this goalie, with penalties, empty nets, overtime and the shootout.

Research, not advice

The most plausible outcome is the likeliest single result of the simulations; it is not a prediction or a guarantee. 21+. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.