Blues vs Penguins prediction

St. Louis Blues at Pittsburgh Penguins, Thursday, November 19, 2026 · PPG Paints Arena. We simulated this game 10,000 times before puck drop, every shift and shot drawn from real play-by-play data for this matchup. Most plausible outcome: Blues 3, Penguins 2.

Most plausible outcome

St. Louis Blues3
Pittsburgh Penguins2

The likeliest final of 10,000 simulated games: the Blues won 56% of them, and this is the result closest to both teams' middle scores.

Top performers

How it played out: every goal

  1. 2ndPIT Rakell (power play), from Karlsson 0–1
  2. 2ndSTL Neighbours (power play), from Broberg and Thomas 1–1
  3. 2ndPIT Robertson, from Crosby and Girard 1–2
  4. 3rdSTL Thomas, from McMichael and Carlo 2–2
  5. 3rdSTL Parayko, from Buchnevich 3–2

Box score

Blues
PlayerGAPTSSOGPMPIMHITBLKTOIFO
Robert Thomas1122001020:346-12
Jake Neighbours1013-103012:341-1
Connor McMichael0112100213:063-5
Pavel Buchnevich0110001013:59
Pius Suter0003020014:095-8
Jimmy Snuggerud0002101020:531-4
Mason McTavish0002100019:373-10
Dylan Holloway0001002117:251-3
Jonatan Berggren0001100012:38
Alexey Toropchenko000000119:482-2
Dalibor Dvorsky0000000014:201-3
Aleksanteri Kaskimaki0000001011:025-7
Philip Broberg0112001429:03
Colton Parayko1012200018:40
Brandon Carlo0110100116:07
Logan Mailloux0002000023:33
Cam Fowler0001-120116:18
Justin Barron0001000112:30
Blues goalies
PlayerSASVGASV%TOI
Joel Hofer30282.93360:00
Penguins
PlayerGAPTSSOGPMPIMHITBLKTOIFO
Rickard Rakell1014-103121:01
Sidney Crosby0113100123:435-17
Nick Robertson1013102018:090-2
Evgeni Malkin0002020016:260-1
Tommy Novak0002-100013:534-7
Connor Dewar0002022015:454-5
Blake Lizotte000200218:472-4
Ben Kindel0001001121:307-13
Hendrix Lapierre0001001012:364-5
Rutger McGroarty0001-20008:56
Egor Chinakhov0000100111:261-1
Justin Brazeau0000-20007:47
Erik Karlsson0114000031:25
Samuel Girard0111100120:49
Kris Letang0002000015:32
Kaedan Korczak0001-100016:47
Declan Carlile0001000115:40
Spencer Stastney0000-200116:04
Penguins goalies
PlayerSASVGASV%TOI
Arturs Silovs24213.87559:57

The breakdown

  1. The setup

    Blues in net: Joel Hofer (confirmed), .915 save % over his recent starts.

    Penguins in net: Arturs Silovs (confirmed), .870 save % over his recent starts.

  2. Who's in the sim

    Blues: Broberg 26 · Thomas 20 · Fowler 20 · Parayko 20 · Mailloux 19 · Carlo 18 (minutes a night)

    Penguins: Karlsson 25 · Crosby 21 · Rakell 20 · Girard 19 · Korczak 19 · Letang 18 (minutes a night)

  3. What decides it

    Blues create the 10th-most dangerous 5-on-5 chances (attempts x shot quality) of 32; Penguins allow the 13th-most.

    Power play 32nd of 32 by chances created vs a penalty kill 21st of 32 at keeping them down.

    Blues take the 2nd-fewest penalties.

    Penguins create the 5th-most dangerous 5-on-5 chances (attempts x shot quality) of 32; Blues allow the 24th-most.

    Power play 30th of 32 by chances created vs a penalty kill 16th of 32 at keeping them down.

  4. Things you'll notice in the sim

    Snuggerud scores in 29% of sims, the likeliest on the Blues.

    Thomas gets a point in 59%.

    Rakell scores in 28% of sims, the likeliest on the Penguins.

    Karlsson gets a point in 56%.

    Overtime in 24% of sims (shootout 12%).

  5. What swings it

    When Silovs stops 92% or more (30% of sims), they win 78%, up from 44%.

    When Hofer stops 92% or more (41% of sims), they win 84%, up from 56%.

    When Penguins score a power-play goal (37% of sims), they win 58%, up from 44%.

  6. Reality check

    Blues score 2.73 a game (last 15). In the sims: 3.4 against this goalie and defense.

    Penguins score 2.67 a game (last 15). In the sims: 3 against this goalie and defense.

  7. The 10,000 vs the market

    The Blues win 56% of the 10,000 games.

    Total 6.5: over in 48%.

    The sims are not built to beat the spread: on past games the side they favored covered about half the time.

This week's simulations

How it works

Every shift puts real lines on the ice by their own ice time at even strength, on the power play and the penalty kill; each skater shoots from his own spots against this goalie, with penalties, empty nets, overtime and the shootout.

Research, not advice

The most plausible outcome is the likeliest single result of the simulations; it is not a prediction or a guarantee. 21+. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.