Blue Jackets vs Islanders prediction

Columbus Blue Jackets at New York Islanders, Tuesday, November 17, 2026 · UBS Arena. We simulated this game 10,000 times before puck drop, every shift and shot drawn from real play-by-play data for this matchup. Most plausible outcome: Islanders 4, Blue Jackets 3.

Most plausible outcome

Columbus Blue Jackets3
New York Islanders4

The likeliest final of 10,000 simulated games: the Islanders won 56% of them, and this is the result closest to both teams' middle scores.

Top performers

How it played out: every goal

  1. 1stCBJ Olivier, from Belluz and Provorov 1–0
  2. 1stCBJ Johnson, from Lomberg and Mateychuk 2–0
  3. 1stCBJ Fantilli (power play), from Knies and Werenski 3–0
  4. 2ndNYI Schenn (power play), from Maccelli 3–1
  5. 3rdNYI Schaefer (power play), from Schenn and Maccelli 3–2
  6. 3rdNYI Holmstrom, from Palmieri and Heineman 3–3
  7. 3rdNYI Kessel, from Eklund 3–4

Box score

Blue Jackets
PlayerGAPTSSOGPMPIMHITBLKTOIFO
Adam Fantilli1014002027:287-14
Kent Johnson1014100021:426-12
Mathieu Olivier1012003111:57
Luca Del Bel Belluz011110004:421-1
Matthew Knies0110003018:34
Ryan Lomberg011010207:521-1
Dmitri Voronkov0003-101115:04
Valeri Nichushkin0002-100020:35
Cole Sillinger0001001017:273-10
Jack Williams0001000010:473-10
Steven Lorentz000102208:044-5
Charlie Coyle0000-100123:155-10
Zach Werenski0115-100527:32
Ivan Provorov0113000321:36
Denton Mateychuk0111000218:20
Damon Severson0002020323:34
Dante Fabbro0001201012:50
Jake Christiansen0001-101010:39
Blue Jackets goalies
PlayerSASVGASV%TOI
Cam Talbot29254.86257:10
Islanders
PlayerGAPTSSOGPMPIMHITBLKTOIFO
Brayden Schenn1121002016:223-7
Matias Maccelli0221020013:40
Simon Holmstrom1014101025:11
Kyle Palmieri0112-102016:323-8
Victor Eklund0111002113:192-4
Emil Heineman0110101012:31
Bo Horvat0004000019:328-15
Jean-Gabriel Pageau0003-102018:1512-17
Ondrej Palat0002103012:13
Anthony Duclair0001-100111:501-4
Casey Cizikas000102217:034-8
Mitchell Chaffee000000007:06
Matthew Schaefer1012-100223:58
Matthew Kessel1012120114:59
Tony DeAngelo0003-121219:47
Ben Hutton0002-101019:00
Adam Pelech0000200325:03
Ryan Pulock0000000116:19
Islanders goalies
PlayerSASVGASV%TOI
Ilya Sorokin32293.90660:00

The breakdown

  1. The setup

    Blue Jackets in net: Cam Talbot (confirmed), .896 save % over his recent starts.

    Islanders in net: Ilya Sorokin (confirmed), .907 save % over his recent starts.

  2. Who's in the sim

    Blue Jackets: Werenski 28 · Mateychuk 22 · Coyle 22 · Severson 22 · Provorov 21 · Fantilli 20 (minutes a night)

    Islanders: Schaefer 27 · Horvat 22 · Pelech 20 · Holmstrom 20 · Pageau 18 · Pulock 18 (minutes a night)

  3. What decides it

    Blue Jackets create the 17th-most dangerous 5-on-5 chances (attempts x shot quality) of 32; Islanders allow the 9th-most.

    Power play 18th of 32 by chances created vs a penalty kill 24th of 32 at keeping them down.

    Blue Jackets take the 4th-fewest penalties.

    Islanders create the 14th-most dangerous 5-on-5 chances (attempts x shot quality) of 32; Blue Jackets allow the 16th-most.

    Power play 28th of 32 by chances created vs a penalty kill 25th of 32 at keeping them down.

  4. Things you'll notice in the sim

    Fantilli scores in 27% of sims, the likeliest on the Blue Jackets.

    Werenski gets a point in 57%.

    Horvat scores in 30% of sims, the likeliest on the Islanders.

    Schaefer gets a point in 63%.

    Overtime in 24% of sims (shootout 13%).

  5. What swings it

    When Talbot stops 92% or more (37% of sims), they win 74%, up from 44%.

    When Sorokin stops 92% or more (43% of sims), they win 82%, up from 56%.

    When Blue Jackets score a power-play goal (38% of sims), they win 58%, up from 44%.

  6. Reality check

    Blue Jackets score 2.27 a game (last 15). In the sims: 2.9 against this goalie and defense.

    Islanders score 3.07 a game (last 15). In the sims: 3.2 against this goalie and defense.

  7. The 10,000 vs the market

    The Islanders win 56% of the 10,000 games.

    Total 5.5: over in 52%.

    The sims are not built to beat the spread: on past games the side they favored covered about half the time.

This week's simulations

How it works

Every shift puts real lines on the ice by their own ice time at even strength, on the power play and the penalty kill; each skater shoots from his own spots against this goalie, with penalties, empty nets, overtime and the shootout.

Research, not advice

The most plausible outcome is the likeliest single result of the simulations; it is not a prediction or a guarantee. 21+. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.